You have to be careful when you are talking about other people’s rotten kids.
Even to define what it means to have a “good” kid or a “bad” kid can be tricky. It’s broad terminology.
Regardless, I couldn’t help but ponder a comment I heard about an obviously “bad” kid who had grown into a bad man. The comment was that his grandparents had raised him and they had “always bought him anything he wanted.”
There was tons of heavy implication within this comment, laid on with a skill that only the elderly Southern lady possesses. I, being skilled in interpreting this clandestine dialect, understood what was really being said. The boy had been “spoiled” by his grandparents and so had turned out to be no good as an adult.
This got me thinking. Does buying too many things for our children turn them into bad people? I have always seen the clichéd images of the over-indulged child throughout my life. The greatest and most recent, of course, being Dudley Dursley. This is archetype of the “bad” child. He has too much of everything. He is bought too much, fed too much, simply given too much. As a result, he (or she) is spoiled.
I’ll be honest. This comment hit me on a personal level.
I have always been guilty of overbuying. I’ve never mortgaged my house to buy my kids something, but if it was in the budget and there was something cool they wanted, or even something cool I thought they might like to have, I probably got it for them.
I love technology and gadgets, so we always have the latest iPhones and iPads. The Boy likes Nike shoes, and I got him a pair. I guess I just never really thought of it as a big deal.
Now, The Boy is 16. He got his first job this summer and is working hard. He does very well in school. So, we got him a car. It’s cheap, it’s small, and it’s not at the top of anyone’s dream car list, but it is new, it gets great gas mileage, and it is his.
So I ask, have we been doing things wrong?
If I go by what society (and some family members) tell me, then we have spoiled children. But the funny thing is, they don’t act like spoiled children.
Obviously, my daughter doesn’t really fit into a simple mold, be it spoiled or not spoiled or anything else, but my son is pretty much a typical 16-year-old boy. However, I happen to think he is an exceptional 16-year-old boy.
He is compassionate and kind. Little kids are drawn to him like moths to a flame. He pretends like this annoys him, but I know he loves them and it brings him joy. He is one of the most generous people I have ever met. I honestly don’t think he has a selfish bone in his body. He works hard and is so smart.
I don’t think it is what we buy our kids that makes them who they are. I think it is what we teach them. You could buy them things and they could be little brats. However, you could also buy them things but still demand that they treat people with respect, and do their chores, and behave a certain way.
Ultimately, it really isn’t anyone’s business what you do or don’t buy for your kids. I think we are all probably guilty of overbuying, especially in this modern age of “stuff.” But the responsibility of raising respectful, responsible children remains the same.
It seems to me blaming the “stuff” is taking the easy way out. It’s easy to blame something superficial like “spoiled” rather than say, “his grandmother let him speak disrespectfully to her all of the time” or “he was never responsible for anything around the house.”
So yes, I think you can spoil your children. But I think you spoil them not by giving them too many material things, but by not giving them enough of what we all need to be decent adults: discipline.
What do you think?